Myanmar's Online Hate Speech & Misinformation Laws

: A Digital Dictatorship

Myanmar's internet laws are among the world's strictest, giving the military junta near-total control over online content. Here's what you need to know:

• VPNs and privacy tools are illegal, with 3-year jail sentences for users
• The military can remove content without court approval
• Vague "fake news" laws target political dissent
• Social media platforms must store user data for 3 years
• Content removal is often instant, with little chance to appeal

Quick Comparison:

Aspect	Myanmar	Global Standards
VPN Use	Banned, jail time	Usually allowed
Content Removal	No court oversight	Often needs court order
Data Retention	Up to 3 years	Typically shorter
Hate Speech Laws	Vague, targets dissent	More specific, protects minorities

These laws affect over 20 million social media users in Myanmar and have real-world consequences. Since 2021, over 3 million people have been displaced due to conflict, and more than 20,500 anti-regime individuals are detained.

The UN warns that Myanmar is creating a "digital dictatorship", far from global standards that balance security and basic rights.

Related video from YouTube

1. Main Laws in Myanmar

Myanmar's online world is shaped by two big laws: the draft Cybersecurity Law and the Telecommunications Law. These laws pack a punch when it comes to what you can say and do online.

1.1 Cybersecurity Law

The draft Cybersecurity Law, cooked up after the 2021 military coup, gives the government some serious muscle over online content. Here's the deal:

• It's not a fan of "misinformation" or "disinformation"
• You'll need to use your real name online
• The authorities can peek at your data
• The military can block websites and hit the kill switch on the internet

And it's no joke. Create some "misinformation" and you could be looking at 3 years behind bars. Internet companies? They've got to take down anything the military doesn't like, including criticism of the big shots.

"Myanmar's military junta has taken a terrible draft cybersecurity law and made it even worse." - Linda Lakhdhir, Asia legal adviser at Human Rights Watch

The law's also got it in for privacy tools. Use a VPN without permission and you might be facing 1-3 years in the slammer and a fine that'll make your wallet weep.

1.2 Telecommunications Law

This law's all about how you chat online. It covers:

• Online money stuff
• How data's stored
• Taking down content

Got more than 100,000 Myanmar users? You've got to keep their data for up to 3 years. Oh, and you need to play ball when the government's investigating "offenses."

The bottom line? These laws have people worried about free speech and privacy. In January 2022, ten international business groups in Myanmar said the cybersecurity law would make it tough for companies to play by the rules.

Both laws give the government a ton of control over Myanmar's online space. They can zap content, punish critics, and get their hands on private data. If you're in Myanmar, you've got to watch what you post or share online. It's a whole new ballgame.

2. Hate Speech Rules

Myanmar's hate speech rules are a big deal, especially online. The government's take on this? Pretty controversial.

2.1 Banned Content Types

The military government's definition of hate speech is broad. Here's the scoop:

• Criticize the military? That's hate speech.
• Insult Buddhism or promote other religions? Banned.
• Stir up ethnic conflicts? Not allowed.

Break these rules? You're looking at up to three years in jail and a 5,000,000 kyat fine (about $1,125).

But here's the thing: these rules are fuzzy. The military often uses them to shut down opposition and control the narrative.

"Myanmar authorities have emboldened hate preachers and silenced human rights advocates." - Independent International Fact-Finding Mission on Myanmar

Let's look at some real examples:

1. The Rohingya Crisis

The military used Facebook to spread fake "jihad attack" warnings in 2017. Result? Real-world violence.

2. Buddhist Extremists

In 2014, a false rape report led to two deaths in Mandalay. Groups like MaBaTha have used social media to spread anti-Muslim hate.

3. Political Censorship

The military has blocked websites and social media platforms, including Facebook, to control information flow.

Civil society groups argue that any new hate speech law should focus on ending impunity, not limiting free speech.

In 2018, Facebook took action:

Action	Result
Banned accounts	Including Myanmar's Commander-in-Chief
Removed pages	Linked to Myanmar military
Reason	Evidence of coordinated hate speech campaign

The takeaway? Myanmar's hate speech rules often serve as a control tool, not protection. If you're posting online in Myanmar, be careful - almost anything could be labeled hate speech if it goes against the military's agenda.

3. False Information Laws

Myanmar's military junta has cracked down on what they call "fake news." In December 2023, they set up a committee to monitor online content 24/7. They can shut down phone numbers and freeze bank accounts without going to court.

What's the catch? The junta decides what's "fake." And their definition is broad.

3.1 How to Spot False Information

In Myanmar, "false information" can be almost anything the military disagrees with. Here's what you need to know:

1. Penal Code Changes

The junta added new rules to the Penal Code:

Section	What It Does	Punishment
505A	Punishes "fear-causing" comments or "false news"	Up to 3 years in prison
505(a)	Targets Civil Disobedience Movement support	Up to 3 years in prison
124A	Criminalizes military criticism	Up to 20 years in prison

2. Electronic Transactions Law

Section 38C makes it illegal to create "misinformation or disinformation" online that causes public panic, loss of trust, or social division. The punishment? One to three years in jail, plus fines.

3. Real-World Impact

These laws are being used:

• 98 journalists arrested since the 2021 coup
• 46 still in jail
• 6 convicted for spreading "false" news

Examples:

• Min Nyo (Democratic Voice of Burma): 3 years for "false" news
• Zaw Zaw (freelance reporter): 2 years for covering protests

"Fake news appears to be any news that the authorities do not want to reach the public." - Phil Robertson, Deputy Asia Director, Human Rights Watch

4. Social Media Focus

The junta has:

• Blocked websites and platforms, including Facebook
• Warned journalists against using terms like "junta"
• Proposed a new cybersecurity law

This law would force online services to keep user data for up to 3 years, hand it over when asked, and block "misinformation" on demand.

The bottom line? In Myanmar, "false information" is whatever the military says it is. Be careful what you post or share online. Almost anything could land you in trouble.

4. How Content is Removed

In Myanmar, content removal is fast and murky. The military junta's committee watches online content 24/7, with the power to take it down without court approval.

Key Aspects of Content Removal:

• The junta's committee monitors content non-stop
• "Harmful" content includes "fake news", porn, and political criticism
• They can shut down phone numbers and freeze bank accounts instantly
• Social media platforms face pressure to remove content quickly

Facebook's Role

Facebook, with 28.7 million Myanmar users, is a big player in content moderation:

Action	Result
Removed accounts	425 Pages, 150 Facebook/Instagram accounts linked to military
Follower impact	At least 2.5 million followers affected
Hate speech detection	Improved from 13% to 63% in one quarter

Nathaniel Gleicher from Facebook admitted: "Facebook has been criticized for moving too slowly to stop the spread of this propaganda."

4.1 Removal Timelines

Content removal in Myanmar is often instant, with little chance to appeal:

• Platforms must act fast on government takedown orders
• Facebook relies heavily on user reports
• AI struggles with Burmese text in hate speech detection

"We don't want Facebook to be used to spread hatred and incite violence. This is especially true in Myanmar where our services can be used to amplify hate or exacerbate harm against the Rohingya." - Mia Garlick, Facebook

Challenges

• Language barriers: Facebook had only two Burmese speakers reviewing posts in early 2015
• Cultural context: Hard to understand local nuances
• No due process: Users can't appeal when content is removed or accounts blocked

The junta's control over internet providers and proposed cybersecurity laws make content removal more about censorship than protection.

sbb-itb-ea3f94f

5. Data Storage Rules

Myanmar's data storage laws? A mix of fuzzy rules and military control. Here's what businesses need to know:

Key Laws

1. Electronic Transactions Law (2021 amendment)
2. Telecommunications Law
3. Law Protecting the Privacy and Security of Citizens (2017)

These give the government wide-ranging access to user data. Oversight? Not so much.

Data Storage Basics

The Electronic Transactions Law sets out some ground rules:

What	How
Data Types	Personal and payment info
How Long	Only as needed
Security	"Adequate measures" required
Consent	Needed for collection and use

But here's the kicker: The military can override these rules.

Military Data Grabs

From February 2021 to February 2022, the military-run Ministry of Transport and Communications hit Telenor with over 200 data requests. The message? Be ready to hand over user data on demand.

Data Localization Plans

The military wants more control. A draft Cyber Security Law from January 2022 would force platforms with 100,000+ Myanmar users to store data on military-controlled servers. Direct access to user info? You bet.

Business Tips

1. Collect only what you need
2. Use strong encryption
3. Be upfront with users about potential government access
4. If possible, store sensitive data outside Myanmar

6. Rules for Online Platforms

Myanmar's online platforms face tough content and data rules. Here's what you need to know:

6.1 Content Checking Rules

Social media companies must:

• Remove content that could harm someone's reputation or job
• Take down posts without waiting for a court order
• Watch for and filter out violent or hateful content
• Act fast when the government asks for content removal

Facebook, big in Myanmar, has had trouble with these rules. In October 2021, a pro-military video calling for violence got 56,000 views before being taken down.

"Hate speech is very language specific. It's hard to do it without people who speak the local language and we need to ramp up our effort there dramatically." - Mark Zuckerberg, Facebook CEO

6.2 User Data Handling

Digital platforms must:

What to do	How to do it
Keep user data	For 3 years
Store user info	Name, IP, phone, ID number, address
Share data	Give user info to authorities when asked
Use local servers	If you have 100,000+ Myanmar users

These rules apply to all "Digital Platform Services" - social media, online markets, search engines, you name it.

Break the rules? You could face fines, service cuts, or lose your license. The government can even shut down your platform if they think it's in the "public interest."

"The proposed cybersecurity law would consolidate the junta's ability to conduct pervasive censorship and surveillance and hamper the operation of businesses in Myanmar." - Linda Lakhdhir, Human Rights Watch

If you're running a digital platform in Myanmar:

1. Keep an eye on the Draft Cybersecurity Law 2.0
2. Get ready to store and share user data
3. Set up strong content monitoring
4. Be prepared to take down content when asked

7. VPN and Privacy Tool Limits

Myanmar's military junta has cracked down hard on online access. Here's what you need to know:

7.1 Allowed and Banned Tools

Since May 30, 2023, most VPNs and privacy tools are banned. The junta wants to control information flow.

Tool	Status
Most VPNs	Illegal
Signal	Blocked
Facebook	Blocked
Independent media	Blocked

Use banned tools? You could face:

• Fines up to 3 million kyats ($1,380)
• Jail time up to 3 years
• Random phone checks

What's still working? Tor browser and some lesser-known VPNs.

The impact? Huge. Internet traffic to many sites has plummeted. People can't get independent info or communicate securely.

"Myanmar is now blocking VPNs at a nationwide level, a rapid step-up in the censorship 'playbook'." - David Peterson, Proton VPN

On the streets:

• Soldiers check phones for VPN apps
• People are getting arrested and fined
• In early June, about two dozen arrests for VPN use

But here's the twist: VPN demand skyrocketed. Proton VPN saw a 1,200% sign-up spike on ban day.

The junta's not stopping at VPNs:

1. Surveillance boost:

• Intercept tech in telecoms
• CCTVs everywhere
• New system to crack web traffic

2. Social media grip:

• Launched MySPACE platform
• Likely harvesting user data

3. Telecom takeover:

• Control over companies
• Internet shutdowns at will

If you're in Myanmar:

• Be super careful with privacy tools
• Keep tabs on working VPNs
• Find safe ways to get info

"The VPN crackdown severely restricts access to accurate information, reinforcing government control." - Simon Migliano, Top10VPN

Bottom line: Myanmar's heading towards what the UN calls a "digital dictatorship."

8. Comparing to Global Standards

Myanmar's online laws don't match up with international norms. Here's the breakdown:

Aspect	Myanmar	Global Standards
Freedom of Expression	Heavily restricted	Protected
VPN Use	Banned, jail time	Usually allowed
Content Removal	No court oversight	Often needs court order
Data Retention	Up to 3 years	Typically shorter
Hate Speech Laws	Vague, targets dissent	More specific, protects minorities

Myanmar's approach? More control, less protection. Let's dive in:

Myanmar uses fuzzy terms like "incorrect information" to make speech illegal. The UN's Rabat Plan? It's way more specific.

Use a VPN in Myanmar? You could end up in jail for 3 years. Most countries? VPNs are fine.

In Myanmar, the military can take down content without a judge's say-so. Many countries require a legal process for that.

The UN says free speech should only be limited when absolutely necessary. Myanmar's laws? They go way overboard.

"The international community can't stay silent while Myanmar denies people their basic rights to free speech, information, and privacy." - UN human rights experts

Myanmar's laws don't tackle the real issues behind hate speech. Instead of protecting vulnerable groups, they often target them.

What's the result? A digital powder keg. In 2014, a fake Facebook post led to riots in Mandalay. Two people died. That's what happens when online hate runs wild.

The bottom line: Myanmar's creating a "digital dictatorship", not a safe online space. It's miles away from global standards that balance security and basic rights.

9. Wrap-up

Myanmar's online laws are tough and vague. They're often used to quiet those who disagree. Here's the key stuff:

• VPNs? Illegal. Use one, and you might spend 3 years in jail.
• The military can take down content without asking a court.
• "Fake news" laws are so broad, they can hit political criticism too.

These rules change fast. Since May 31, 2023, the junta's added new internet limits. They've even set up a 24/7 team to watch for "fake news" and political criticism.

Why care? It affects over 20 million social media users in Myanmar. And it's not just about online stuff. These laws hit real life:

In 2014, a fake Facebook post sparked riots in Mandalay. Two people died.

Since October 2023:

• Over 3 million people have had to leave their homes due to conflict.
• More than 20,500 people seen as anti-regime are locked up.

Impact	Number
Social media users affected	20+ million
People forced from homes	3+ million
Anti-regime detainees	20,500+

UN human rights experts are worried: "The world can't just watch while Myanmar's people lose their basic rights."

Staying in the know is crucial. These laws can flip overnight. They change how people talk, share info, and stay safe online. If you're in Myanmar or deal with it, keeping up isn't just smart—it's a must.

Related posts

• Myanmar's Internet Laws: Digital Rights Update 2024
• Myanmar's Digital Repression 2024: Censorship, Surveillance, Shutdowns
• ASEAN Cross-Border Data Flow Regulations 2024
• Myanmar E-Commerce Guidelines 2024: Key Features